CCUS Fundamentals | The High Cost of Carbon Capture

byAmyra Mardhani, Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) Contributor

Enverus Intelligence® Research’s recently released CCUS Fundamentals highlights the extremely challenging economics of direct air capture (DAC). Our analysis finds DAC projects are only viable with support from premium carbon dioxide removal (CDR) credits. Currently quoted at ~$600/tonne, the credits are crucial for offsetting high capital and operating costs.

A key milestone on the road to commercialization is OXY subsidiary 1PointFive’s Texas Stratos facility, which is set to begin carbon sequestration by year-end. At $1.3 billion, the world’s largest DAC plant — with a nameplate capacity of 0.5 mtpa of CO2 — must contract more than 43% of of its credits to remain profitable. The challenge for Stratos and the broader DAC sector is securing high-priced offtake agreements to ensure positive returns, with CDR credit contracting emerging as the most effective strategy.

1PointFive has secured ~1.35 million tonnes of CDR credits through multi-year agreements, with Microsoft and Airbus being its largest buyers (Figure 1); this is significant but still well below the threshold we estimate is needed to be NPV positive. Most are contracted through 2030 or earlier, creating uncertainty about future cash flows and raising concerns about the project’s long-term viability.

The Sweetwater Cardon Storage Hub has completed the nation’s deepest carbon storage well in Wyoming. At 18,437 ft, it’s about 3x the depth of the Grand Canyon. The target was chosen for geological advantages, including denser CO₂ storage, greater safety margins and avoidance of interference with existing wells.

Research Highlights:

  • CCUS – Gigatonne Dreams, Market Realities – The 2025 CCUS Play Fundamentals examines changes across the CCUS landscape over the past year, highlighting shifts in momentum, evolving policy frameworks and emerging opportunities. The report analyzes deployment challenges from permitting delays and public pushback, as well as the rise of credit stacking, low-carbon power and next-generation capture and sequestration technologies. Key players, cost trends and technology readiness are explored to identify where value and competitive advantage are emerging.

  • Chasing Connection – Interconnection Timelines and Economics Post-OBBBA – This white paper for POWER Magazine outlines the state of the interconnection queue, project timelines, delays and project economics following the passing of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. We examine the impacts on project economics and feasibility as tax credit timelines grow closer and projects rush to connect.

About Enverus Intelligence® | Research, Inc. (EIR)

Enverus Intelligence® | Research, Inc. (EIR) is a subsidiary of Enverus that publishes energy-sector research focused on the oil, natural gas, power and renewable industries. EIR publishes reports including asset and company valuations, resource assessments, technical evaluations, and macroeconomic forecasts and helps make intelligent connections for energy industry participants, service companies, and capital providers worldwide. See additional disclosures here.

Picture of Amyra Mardhani, Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) Contributor

Amyra Mardhani, Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) Contributor

Amyra joined the Enverus Intelligence® Research team, focusing on Energy Transition Research, in September 2024. She studied Business Analytics at the University of Calgary and brings nearly two years of experience in investment management from the private wealth industry. With a strong background in data analysis and financial insights, Amyra is passionate about leveraging data to support strategic decisions in the evolving energy sector.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content
enverus-power-and-renewables-grid
Post
ByEnverus

Ask questions in plain language and quickly turn complex information into structured comparisons, scenarios and actionable insights.

Natural gas power M&A premiums double as data center demand and capital costs transform U.S. energy market
Post
Power & Renewables, Power Trading+1
  • Utilities
ByEnverus

EIR’s PJM and MISO winter outlook: a record El Niño, capped capacity auctions, MISO scarcity risk and heat rate forecasts for Dec. through Feb.

power-grid-congestion
Post
Power Trading, Utilities
ByEnverus

Based on the Enverus Winter Power Market Outlook webinar for ERCOT and SPP, presented by Adam Jordan, Director of Power Analytics. ERCOT has produced only 15 to 30 hours above 60 GW of net load in each of the last...

Aging-power-plant_1418205261-1
Post
Power & Renewables, Power Trading+1
  • Utilities
ByEnverus

EIR’s ISO-NE and NYISO winter outlook: how NECEC and CHPE reshape Northeast spreads, plus RGGI costs, El Niño weather and heat rate forecasts.

Enverus releases Top 50 Public E&P Operators of 2025
Post
Operators
ByRyan Hill

Operators are testing overlooked Osborn and Cherokee zones in Oklahoma as core inventory thins. See what Enverus data shows about remaining inventory.

Time-to-power gap Big generation’s Achilles’ heel in the AI data center race
Post
Power & Renewables, Power Trading
ByEnverus

PJM has 113.6 GW of announced large-load capacity, far more than the 28.5 GW under construction. See what the gap means for reliability and planning.

U.S. natural gas prices face power demand drag
Post
Power & Renewables, Power Trading
ByEnverus

ERCOT data shows large loads ramping at different rates as solar and battery additions keep pace, with new supply expected to slow in 2027.

Global energy markets brace for supply shock and further price gains
Post
Trading & Risk
ByAl Salazar, Enverus Intelligence® Research (EIR) Contributor

Bank of Canada energy inflation risks stagflation as oil spikes push headline inflation higher ahead of a pivotal rate decision.

Enverus Press Release - Speed through records with Enverus Instant Analyst™ - Courthouse
Post
Financial Services
ByColton Wright

Where will future oil inventory come from? Explore the Barnett-Woodford estimate and the spacing and cost assumptions investors should test.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Ready to Subscribe?

Ready to Get Started?