Power & Renewables

CO2 pipeline economics: The missing link

Model analyzes transportation economics in the carbon capture, usage and storage value chain

byEnverus

CALGARY, Alberta (April 2, 2024) — Enverus Intelligence Research (EIR), a subsidiary of Enverus, the leading generative AI and energy-dedicated SaaS company, has developed a CO2 Pipeline Economic Model that can be used to analyze transportation economics in the carbon, capture, usage and storage (CCUS) value chain.

Utilizing the CO2 Pipeline Economic Model, a new EIR report analyzes the differences between CO2 and natural gas pipelines and outlines the importance of minimizing CO2 transportation costs through hub and trunkline pipeline designs. For example, EIR has used the model to analyze the canceled Navigator CO2 Heartland Greenway project economics to illustrate the hub-scale economics the project was targeting.

“With carbon capture gaining momentum as a method to lower emissions, many industries still face challenges in terms of economic viability for the entire capture and storage value chain,” said Jeffery Jen, senior associate at EIR.

“A key component of the overall cost and ultimate success of these projects will be their transportation strategies — whether they can leverage trunkline designs to connect to higher-quality storage reservoirs and reduce transportation and storage costs,” Jen said. “EIR calculates that projects should target bundled captured emissions of 12-18 million tonnes per annum (mtpa) as part of their transportation strategies to minimize transportation costs and maximize profitability.”

Key takeaways:

  • Only 290 mtpa, or 13%, of U.S. emissions break even below $85/tonne assuming top decile storage costs. Developing transportation strategies that utilize trunkline design to maximize flow rate while connecting emitters to higher-quality reservoirs will be a key strategy for profitable CCUS projects.
  • The CO2 transportation breakeven ranges from $0.85-$15.90/tonne, contingent on optimal flow rates of 12-18 mtpa.
  • Labor and materials constitute 50% of the CO2 transportation breakeven, creating cost escalations more than 10 times caused by locational disparities in labor costs, access to materials and terrain variability.
  • The canceled Navigator CO2 Heartland Greenway project showed cost savings of almost 10 times through the utilization of a trunkline design. The CO2 transportation breakeven would have been under $10/tonne with 15 mtpa of capacity.
  • With the addition of the CO2 Transportation Economic Model, EIR can now model the economics of the entire CCUS value chain.
Enverus graph showing Co2 transportation breakeven for various flow rates and distances

EIR’s analysis pulls from a variety of Enverus products including Energy Transition Research and Enverus Infrastructure.

You must be an Enverus Intelligence® subscriber to access this report.

About Enverus Intelligence Research
Enverus Intelligence ® | Research, Inc. (EIR) is a subsidiary of Enverus that publishes energy-sector research focused on the oil, natural gas, power and renewable industries. EIR publishes reports including asset and company valuations, resource assessments, technical evaluations and macro-economic forecasts; and helps make intelligent connections for energy industry participants, service companies and capital providers worldwide. Enverus is the most trusted, generative AI and energy-dedicated SaaS platform, offering real-time access to analytics, insights and benchmark cost and revenue data sourced from our partnerships to 98% of U.S. energy producers, and more than 35,000 suppliers. Learn more at Enverus.com.

Media Contact: Jon Haubert | 303.396.5996

View all press releases at Enverus.com/newsroom.

Picture of Enverus

Enverus

Energy’s most trusted SaaS platform — creating intelligent connections that uncover insights and opportunities to deliver extraordinary outcomes.

Related News

China’s Order No. 837 adds project-delay risk to U.S. power supply chains
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research examines how China’s Order No. 837 could add project-delay risk for U.S. power developers through new approval requirements for technical support.

Who the FERC is ready Grading grid readiness for large loads
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research evaluates U.S. grid readiness for large data center loads, finding SPP ahead on regulatory certainty while major PJM and MISO project pipelines remain exposed to timing and cost risks.

Behind-the-meter generation forecast Skipping the queue
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research forecasts 25.5 GW of U.S. industrial demand will rely on behind-the-meter generation through 2030, with data centers driving 88% of demand and speed-to-power shaping technology choices.

Race to resiliency Tax-credit phaseout expected to push renewable PPA prices higher
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research identifies 759 planned U.S. wind and solar projects that may require higher PPA prices to remain economic as federal clean electricity tax credits phase out.

New forecast separates organic electricity demand from structural load growth
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research’s 80-zone Lower 48 forecast separates organic electricity demand from data centers, EVs and other structural drivers to clarify the baseline outlook through 2050.

Off the grid, on the gas
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

EIR forecasts 62 GW of new U.S. data center capacity by 2030, as grid constraints drive behind-the-meter natural gas generation and demand growth.

Cheaper to buy: Gas plant acquisitions remain well below newbuild costs
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research finds existing gas-fired power assets are trading at roughly half the cost of new CCGT construction, supporting incumbent valuations and challenging merchant newbuild economics.

800 VDC rewrites AI data center power economics
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research analyzes how 800 VDC architecture could lower AI data center electrical capex, improve facility efficiency and reduce copper intensity.

Enverus cuts U.S. EV adoption forecast due to federal policy changes and slower market growth
Newsroom
Financial Services, Power & Renewables
ByJon Haubert

Enverus Intelligence® Research’s latest EV forecast shows how slower U.S. adoption after federal tax credit changes shifts grid load timing, regional ISO exposure and ICE vehicle displacement through 2035.

Find Out How Enverus Can Help Your Business
Subscribe to the Energy Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Get Started

Sign up for our Blog

Ready to Subscribe?

Ready to Get Started?