Power and Renewables

Powering through outage season: A breakdown of PJM’s WHUB/NIHUB spread

byKenneth Curtis

It’s that time of year when generator and transmission outages are at their peak in PJM. The first half of April has not disappointed volatility-wise as the WHUB/NIHUB spread has set new 30-day highs largely driven by congestion.

Figure 1: Day-ahead WHUB/NIHUB MCC spread for the last 30 days with the constraints driving this spread split out below

Among the top constraints to impact this spread are CHIC_AVE – PRAXAR (138KV) and WEED-MAHO (138KV) in northern Illinois, which discount NIHUB when binding. 

Figure 2: Top three day-ahead binding constraints impacting NIHUB for the last 30 days

Using MUSE’s decomposition views to breakdown the drivers of these constraints by transmission outages, generation and load, we can quickly see if outage season is the driver behind these constraints.

Looking at constraint flows and decompositions for CHIC_AVE – PRAXAR (138KV) we can see the frequency of DA binding has increased with two outages that began in March. These outages don’t roll off until May, indicating this may continue to be a driver of the WHUB/NIHUB spread. 

Figure 3: MUSE constraint decomposition for CHIC_AVE – PRAXAIR (138KV)

Next, let’s dive into WEED-MAHO (138KV), wherewe can see day-ahead binding events increasing in frequency with two outages that began in March. Recently, however, an additional outage has started that is relieving this congestion, decreasing the frequency of DA binding events. This gives a signal that the congestion may alleviate and, in turn, reduce pressure on the WHUB/NIHUB spread.

Figure 3: Real-time/day-ahead shadow prices for WEED-MAHO (138KV) with base decompositions below

Outage analysis on WEED-MAHO (138KV) is possible due to MUSE PJM’s new Base Decomposition feature. With this feature, you can now understand the impact of transmission outages on congestion for any constraint, even ones without constraint flows, giving you a leading indicator for decision making this outage season.

Do you have other spread you would like to analyze? Want to see how MUSE could help you make faster, more confident decisions? Let us help you be the first to know exactly why new constraints bind. 

Picture of Kenneth Curtis

Kenneth Curtis

Kenneth Curtis is a Director of Power Markets at Enverus. His career includes serving as an East Power Trader at Twin Eagle, focusing primarily on the physical flow of power, and as a Power Trader & Asset Manager for EDF Trading, concentrating on the East & West regions.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content
Enverus Press Release - Undo the queue: Enverus acquires Pearl Street Technologies to solve for a more reliable, resilient grid
Energy Market Wrap
ByEnverus

NextEra’s landmark utility merger leads this week’s Energy Market Wrap, alongside Permian dealmaking, LNG expansion and rising infrastructure investment.

Enverus Press Release - Upstream M&A sails on with $30 billion in 2Q24
Minerals
ByHasmik Belich

Prime shale inventory is getting harder to find and more expensive to acquire. The mineral acquisition market is more competitive than it has ever been. Enverus Evaluate and Acquire brings together forecasting, inventory modeling and economic valuation in one connected...

Enverus Press Release - OFS prices expected to bottom out by year’s end
Analyst Takes
ByAl Salazar, Enverus Intelligence® Research (EIR) Contributor

Analysis of Brent crude price impact Strait of Hormuz Canadian energy and why Canada has supply leverage amid geopolitical risk.

Enverus Press Release - Enverus Earns Top Workplaces Honors for Fourth Consecutive Year
Minerals
ByHasmik Belich

MARC is where the minerals and royalty world comes to compare notes. This year, I came away with a clear sense that the macro environment is finally forcing the conversations the industry has been putting off — inventory quality, capital...

Enverus Press Release - Enverus releases inaugural Top US Drillers and customer rankings
Energy Market Wrap
ByEnverus

Deals, IPO activity and LNG growth drive this week’s Energy Market Wrap, alongside rising oil output, midstream expansion and continued carbon project challenges.

Carbon storage in question: Illinois regulation could threaten key CCUS projects
Business Automation Minerals
ByPhillip Dunning

In the oil and gas industry, automated clearing house (ACH) fraud and change-of-bank scams create real exposure on both sides of a royalty payment. For operators, a fraudulent account update can mean sending funds to the wrong place — and...

Enverus Intelligence® Research Press Release - OPEC+ cuts and Trump tariffs force price downgrade
Financial Services
ByColton Wright

For years, natural gas pipelines were a straightforward asset class — stable throughput, predictable demand, reliable returns. That’s changing fast. The AI boom is driving a surge in power demand that’s reshaping how gas moves through the U.S. interstate pipeline...

Enverus Press Release - Welcome to EVOLVE 2025: Where visionaries converge to shape the future of energy
Power and Renewables
ByEnverus

As we head into a new coincident peak (CP) season across North America, it is a great time to revisit what CP programs are, how they work across major ISOs, and how Enverus performed during last summer’s season. What Is...

Enverus releases Top 50 Public E&P Operators of 2024
Energy Market Wrap
ByEnverus

Western buys Brazos for $1.6B, Keyera pushes its Plains deal, Expro adds MPD tech, Chevron holds steady, and Exxon expects tight markets to persist.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Ready to Subscribe?

Ready to Get Started?