Power and Renewables

The Texas power market evolution

A look at performance credit mechanism, bridging solutions and the Texas Energy Insurance Program

byScott Bruns

Performance credit mechanism

In a decision that could reshape Texas’ power market, The Public Utilities Commission of Texas (PUCT) voted Jan. 17 to adopt the performance credit mechanism (PCM) market design, a strategy developed by consultant E3 in partnership with the commission. The PCM mechanism aims to provide payments to power units that are available during peak conditions, incentivizing reliable capacity and retaining generator assets at risk of retirement. Although resembling capacity mechanisms in deregulated markets such as California’s CAISO, the PUCT emphasized that PCM is not a capacity market feature.

Bridging solutions

As the PCM market design takes shape, discussions have focused on bridge solutions for the transition given that the redesign will take several years to implement. With the long timeline, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) board recently voted in conjunction with the PUCT to enact a bridging mechanism. The bridging solutions involves changing of the operating reserve demand curve (ORDC). In lieu of a capacity market like most other deregulated independent system operators (ISO), the ORDC mechanism adds money to ERCOT’s real-time prices when the buffer of capacity available to react to large system disturbances fall below a certain reliability limit. This buffer of online idle generating capacity is often called operating reserves, or online reserves.

Historically, these adders were a function of an exponential curve and at higher levels of reserves are mere pennies; however, as the reliability limit ERCOT establishes nears, these prices skyrocket to the price cap. The changes reflect two new characteristics to the curve. At an operating reserves level (PRC) at or below 7,000 megawatts a price floor to the curve of $10/MWh, at or below 6,500 megawatts, a price floor is increased to $20/MWh.


To understand why this level is important, one can look back to historical operating conditions. This newly adjusted range is where operating reserves spend a significant amount of time exhibited in the yellow bars in the histogram below.

ERCOT expects the adjustment will add $500 million annually to the cost of power. This change has an asymmetric benefit to thermal units over renewable units which are known to push operating reserves well above the 7,000-megawatt floor. The original ORDC curve still allows prices to exceed these price floors as PRC decreases, which eventually reaches the $5,000/MWh price cap as reserves fall enough. This bridging solution is expected to take four months or longer to develop, so not a risk for this summer’s trading but will potentially impact fall/winter 2023 as maintenance outage season begins again.


More on PCM

The Texas House State Affairs Committee convened March 1 to discuss grid reliability and the proposed PCM design. The Committee heard testimonies from ERCOT CEO Pablo Vegas, Zach Ming of E3, PUCT Chairman Peter Lake and other industry representatives. As the 88th Texas Legislature Session approaches its conclusion May 29, PCM appears poised to pass with minimal additional legislative scrutiny.

Senate Bill 6

In parallel, Senate Bill 6 (SB 6), introduced Jan. 19, 2023, proposes the Texas Energy Insurance Program and the Texas Energy Infrastructure Fund, providing financial assistance for new thermal generation and infrastructure improvements. A revamped version of the “Berkshire Hathaway bill,” SB 6 aims to address reliability concerns following Winter Storm Uri by establishing 10,000 megawatts of “reliability assets” outside the ERCOT market structure. The estimated cost of $8-16 billion will be passed directly through to consumers. Eyebrows were raised as the Lower Colorado River Valley Authority (LCRA) appeared to be throwing their hat in the ring to build these units, which would likely require it to change its status from a public non-profit in charge of waterways to some unknown new business entity.

While ERCOT supports the bill for grid reliability, critics argue it may increase costs, impact the ERCOT wholesale market and limit future investment. SB 6 also restricts eligible participants for new plant construction, potentially benefiting only the largest power generators and river authorities like LCRA.

After passing the Senate Feb. 15, 2023, SB 6 is under consideration by the House Energy Resources Committee. The committee is currently considering it on agenda items and should soon begin discussions on items from the Senate given the close of the legislative session. If passed, it will proceed to the full House, Senate conference committee and, potentially, the governor’s desk.

The proposals signal a potential shift in legislators’ thinking on the Texas power markets. Historically, free and open markets have driven renewable and technology expansion. Stakeholders, including market participants, private equity firms and market analysts, are raising important questions about the bill’s implications. A key concern is the uncertainty about who would be responsible for building the next power generation plant if the bill is enacted. The outcome of these legislative efforts will shape the future of Texas power markets.

Keep your eye on the House committees and the Texas State Legislature over the coming weeks!

We discuss many important topics for power traders and developers in our Flash Publication 90-Day Reports which come out every two weeks for CAISO, ERCOT, PJM, MISO, Mid-C, NYISO, ISONE and SPP.

Learn more about how Enverus’ Power Market Publications can help you navigate the Texas power market evolution.

Scott Bruns

Scott Bruns

Scott Bruns is a senior power analyst at Enverus. Before joining Enverus, Scott traded physical and financial power for nearly a decade at Direct Energy. Changing focus, he moved into the fundamental analysis group at Direct where he focused on developing congestion models and provided traders with short- and long-term price views. In his spare time, Scott enjoys enhancing his Python programming skills and taking his puppy to the dog park with his wife and children. Scott has a bachelor’s degree in mathematics from the University of Houston.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content

Enverus Blog - Analyst takes: 6 January energy trends you need to know
ByErin Faulkner

Over the last few quarters, executives at U.S. upstream operators have grown accustomed to analysts asking about cost inflation. It’s an inevitable part of every conference call. During the late July to mid-August earnings season for Q2, the question shifted...

Enverus Blog - Energy Transition Today: EPA jumpstarts EV uptake
Energy Transition
ByKevin Kang

Behind the meter (BTM) solar is a key factor in decreasing load in CAISO, especially in California where it has the most impact on annual demand. The state’s potential for nearly 195 GW of rooftop solar capacity exists, although its...

Enverus Blog - 3 price management capabilities to offset cost inflation
Energy Transition
ByKiana Cruz

Seismic surveys are a vital tool in the oil and gas industry. Effective use of seismic surveys allows industry professionals to identify prospects, assess potential resources, reduce risk and even quantify reserves – in short, to make well-informed decisions that...

Energy Transition
ByAlex Nevokshonoff

While we are still waiting for guidelines from the IRS regarding hydrogen incentives released with the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) last year, it is clear that supportive policy must be in place for green hydrogen to compete in existing hydrogen...

Enverus Press Release - Breaking down the CCUS basins
Energy Analytics Energy Transition

Panel discussion with CCUS experts from Enverus EVOLVE Conference Introduction CCUS offers a promising solution to curb greenhouse gas emissions by capturing CO2 from industrial sources and power plants and storing it underground. CCUS has gained significant attention in recent...

Analyst Takes
ByChris Griggs

As we usher in the month of August, it’s an ideal moment for retrospection on the past month’s shifts and trends in the energy sector. Our proficient Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) team has delved into critical trends and innovations,...

Energy Transition
ByCarson Kearl

The Vogtle Unit 3 nuclear reactor began its commercial operations at the end of July. Based in Georgia, the facility will provide clean electricity to the southeast U.S. for likely longer than the next half-century. This marks the first U.S....

Enverus News Release - Energy impacts of Gulf of Mexico hurricanes quantified
Trading and Risk

Navigating dynamic commodity markets and managing large volumes of data is no small task. That’s why we’ve built a powerful CTRM solution to help aggregate and leverage more than 500 data sources alongside your own proprietary data, providing an unsurpassed...

Energy Transition
ByScott Wilmot

Historical factors and trends are becoming less descriptive of future power demand. The growing pace of electrification and electric vehicle (EV) adoption are changing the power demand dynamics. At the same time, more customers are installing behind-the-meter (BTM) generation to...

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Register Today

Get Energy Transition Research updates straight to your inbox by filling out the form below.

Sign Up

Power Your Insights

Connect with an Expert

Access Product Tour

Speak to an Expert