Power and Renewables

Powering through outage season: A breakdown of PJM’s WHUB/NIHUB spread

byKenneth Curtis
May 8, 2023

It’s that time of year when generator and transmission outages are at their peak in PJM. The first half of April has not disappointed volatility-wise as the WHUB/NIHUB spread has set new 30-day highs largely driven by congestion.

Figure 1: Day-ahead WHUB/NIHUB MCC spread for the last 30 days with the constraints driving this spread split out below

Among the top constraints to impact this spread are CHIC_AVE – PRAXAR (138KV) and WEED-MAHO (138KV) in northern Illinois, which discount NIHUB when binding. 

Figure 2: Top three day-ahead binding constraints impacting NIHUB for the last 30 days

Using MUSE’s decomposition views to breakdown the drivers of these constraints by transmission outages, generation and load, we can quickly see if outage season is the driver behind these constraints.

Looking at constraint flows and decompositions for CHIC_AVE – PRAXAR (138KV) we can see the frequency of DA binding has increased with two outages that began in March. These outages don’t roll off until May, indicating this may continue to be a driver of the WHUB/NIHUB spread. 

Figure 3: MUSE constraint decomposition for CHIC_AVE – PRAXAIR (138KV)

Next, let’s dive into WEED-MAHO (138KV), wherewe can see day-ahead binding events increasing in frequency with two outages that began in March. Recently, however, an additional outage has started that is relieving this congestion, decreasing the frequency of DA binding events. This gives a signal that the congestion may alleviate and, in turn, reduce pressure on the WHUB/NIHUB spread.

Figure 3: Real-time/day-ahead shadow prices for WEED-MAHO (138KV) with base decompositions below

Outage analysis on WEED-MAHO (138KV) is possible due to MUSE PJM’s new Base Decomposition feature. With this feature, you can now understand the impact of transmission outages on congestion for any constraint, even ones without constraint flows, giving you a leading indicator for decision making this outage season.

Do you have other spread you would like to analyze? Want to see how MUSE could help you make faster, more confident decisions? Let us help you be the first to know exactly why new constraints bind. 

Picture of Kenneth Curtis

Kenneth Curtis

Kenneth Curtis is a Director of Power Markets at Enverus. His career includes serving as an East Power Trader at Twin Eagle, focusing primarily on the physical flow of power, and as a Power Trader & Asset Manager for EDF Trading, concentrating on the East & West regions.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content

Enverus and Pexapark Press Release - Enverus Enhances Global Trading & Risk Platform with Pexapark’s Benchmark Renewables Pricing and Market Intelligence
Energy Transition
ByCarson Kearl, Enverus Intelligence® Research (EIR) Contributor
December 3, 2025

Enverus Intelligence® Research (EIR) estimates an average load growth of about 12 GW in PJM by 2035, driven primarily by data center load expansion. PJM’s independent market monitor filed a complaint arguing the grid operator has clear authority to delay...

Enverus Press Release - Enverus releases “2025 Interconnection Queue Outlook” to navigate backlogged grid challenges
Power and Renewables
ByEnverus
December 2, 2025

October in ERCOT brought a mix of seasonal challenges—unusually warm temperatures early in the month, a sharp cooldown later, and notable variability in renewable generation. These conditions tested the accuracy of short-term and day-ahead forecasts, which are essential for power...

Enverus Press Release - Enverus honored as one of Alberta’s leading employers
Energy Analytics Operators
ByAlexandra Castaneda
December 1, 2025

Uncover hidden insights for Canadian heavy oil multilateral wells. Enverus PRISM provides comprehensive data to benchmark, evaluate designs, and identify emerging strategies like fishbone wells.

Enverus Intelligence® Research Press Release - Delayed data center demand response: How quickly can ISOs add new loads?
Business Automation
ByEnverus
November 28, 2025

Field ticketing is the backbone of service validation and payment in upstream oil and gas operations—but for many operators, it’s also a source of daily headaches. From paperwork overload to payment delays and coding disputes, the challenges are real and...

Enverus Press Release - The Denver Post names Enverus a Top Workplace in Colorado
Analyst Takes Trading and Risk
ByAl Salazar, Enverus Intelligence® Research (EIR) Contributor
November 24, 2025

Unlock insights into Canada's energy potential. Analyze policy shifts, pipeline development, and LNG Canada's role in meeting global energy demand.

Enverus Intelligence® Research Press Release - Wood you believe it? BECCS is taking off and creating overlooked, lucrative opportunities
Energy Market Wrap
ByEnverus
November 21, 2025

DT Midstream expands Haynesville, Texas gains CCS primacy, BOEM plans offshore lease sale, and Chevron boosts Permian recovery—get the full energy update.

Enverus Intelligence® Research Press Release - Waha prices expected to go negative (again)
Energy Transition
ByAshmal Dawoodani, Enverus Intelligence® Research
November 20, 2025

Blackstone announced last week it will invest about $1.2 billion to build the Wolf Summit Energy Project in West Virginia as forecast load growth in the region continues to drive demand for baseload generation. In contrast to earlier announcements of...

Enverus/RatedPower Press Release - RatedPower publishes 2025 Global Renewable Trends Report examining the green landscape
Energy Market Wrap
ByEnverus
November 14, 2025

Top energy stories: Baytex exits U.S., Chevron’s growth plan, Harvest LNG deal, Energy Transfer records, and Baker Hughes LNG order.

Enverus Press Release - Modeling EPA’s new Subpart W revision and the super-emitter wild card
Energy Analytics Geoscience Analytics
BySarah Peters Lancaster
November 14, 2025

Inventory scarcity is no longer a distant concern; it’s here, and it’s reshaping upstream strategies. As Tier 1 inventory dwindles and energy demand rises, operators face mounting pressure to discover, extend and optimize resources in increasingly complex environments. The subsurface...

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Register Today

Sign Up

Power Your Insights

Connect with an Expert

Access Product Tour

Speak to an Expert