Energy Transition Trading and Risk

Energy Transition: The Role of Hydrogen Q&A 


Last month, Ian Nieboer from our Enverus Intelligence team teamed up with Tim Hard, Senior Vice President of Energy Transition from Argus, to provide expert insights on the market dynamics of hydrogen, including: 

  • Where emerging market opportunities are for hydrogen 
  • How to make market assessments using MarketView 
  • Best practices for energy trading and risk management 

Missed the live discussion? Watch the on-demand webinar to hear all the insights and to learn how Enverus Trading & Risk solutions can help ensure you have the accurate and timely data you need to act. 

During the webinar, we received a number of questions from the audience and wanted to share some of those questions and answers here. Thank you to Tim and Ian for keeping the conversation going! 

Q: Europe looks set to lead the new hydrogen economy. What differences between Europe, the U.S. and Asia stand out to you? 

A: The U.S. is the most generous and loosest in rule stringency. The EU will be offering less and aim to stipulate more. Asia is problematic as Australia is low-balling the supply support funding, while Japan and Korea, though large individual economies, lack the EU/U.S. heft, nor have they joined policy up between them. Yet. 

Q: What do you see for competing technologies that could impair or stop that launch for hydrogen? Carbon capture, methane pyrolysis? 

A: The issue with methane pyrolysis is that technology is not there yet, and probably won’t be there until 2030, and there are a lot of assumptions as to what natural gas is going to do up to that point. Carbon capture is important, it is going to be used. Is it going to negate the need for hydrogen molecules, no? It is just not economic, and we need solutions now. 

Q: How do you see costs impacting the development of the hydrogen economy? 

A: It is costly at the moment, but cost will fall as scale increases. Every time there is a change to something else, cost is brought up. The cost is an issue, but the need is there. 

Q: Are there catalysts on the horizon that are a launching pad on the demand side? 

A: On the European side we have seen SAF being injected into mandates. It’s only electric going forward and you have two options electric vehicles (EV) or fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) which are powered by hydrogen, so you are starting to see those mandates coming through. 

Q: Is the industry developing consensus on the which investment structures are best suited to hydrogen development? What does that look like?  

A: Developers are strongly pushing to ensure offtake agreements are tied up (fully for stage 1s), before progressing to FID. 

Q: What lessons should U.S. developers of hydrogen take from Europe, elsewhere?  

A: Simple is best. Developers crave certainty before spades hit ground. Otherwise, I think it may be the other way round. The U.S. could take a leaf out of Europe’s book and look to carbon disincentives (taxes), as its northern neighbor Canada is doing. 

Q: Is it reasonable to think that hydrogen will fuel more than 5% of the btu content a modern 500 MW CC plant produces? 

A: Yes. Peaker plants need to continue to avoid intermittency problems and their co-firing rates should continue to rise.  

Q: The shipping industry has reduced oil spills, but they are not perfect. How do you assess the risk of ammonia spills as a shipping fuel? 

A: High. The industry has a stellar record, but size increasing by a factor of five increases risk of accidents beyond that factor. More of a concern is NH3 as a vector. A marine fuel spill is necessarily smaller scale than a cargo travelling Aus-NE Asia, the most biodiverse marine corridor globally. 

Q: Do you believe that Brazil has space on this H2 opportunities?  

A: Massive, undoubtedly. Low cost, huge land mass, great RE profiles. 

Q: The electrolyser capacity mentioned, is it single stack?  

A: Argus model in 1MW stack size for PEM (in 100MW total scale) and in 5MW for ALK. 

Q: What are the key factors to reduce the H2 cost? 

A: Cheap renewable energy ‘in’ to electrolysers via levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) is a huge driver for green hydrogen, while cheap gas/coal achieves the same for blue. As gas prices have fallen faster than LCOE, the cost differential between ‘renewable vs fossil’ has really opened, as below.  

Carbon costs will further incentivize the switch from grey to blue and green – albeit there’s likely less room to run in the EU than in APAC/ME/ROW. The U.S. has effectively put a price of $85/t of CO2 in credits, which is within striking distance of EU C02 costs. 

Watch the on-demand webinar to see the full conversation and learn more.

Fill out the form to speak to an Energy Transition expert, and learn more about the featured MarketView solutions.



Energy’s most trusted SaaS platform — creating intelligent connections that uncover insights and opportunities to deliver extraordinary outcomes.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content

Enverus Blog - Analyst takes: 6 January energy trends you need to know
ByErin Faulkner

Over the last few quarters, executives at U.S. upstream operators have grown accustomed to analysts asking about cost inflation. It’s an inevitable part of every conference call. During the late July to mid-August earnings season for Q2, the question shifted...

Enverus Blog - Energy Transition Today: EPA jumpstarts EV uptake
Energy Transition
ByKevin Kang

Behind the meter (BTM) solar is a key factor in decreasing load in CAISO, especially in California where it has the most impact on annual demand. The state’s potential for nearly 195 GW of rooftop solar capacity exists, although its...

Enverus Blog - 3 price management capabilities to offset cost inflation
Energy Transition
ByKiana Cruz

Seismic surveys are a vital tool in the oil and gas industry. Effective use of seismic surveys allows industry professionals to identify prospects, assess potential resources, reduce risk and even quantify reserves – in short, to make well-informed decisions that...

Energy Transition
ByAlex Nevokshonoff

While we are still waiting for guidelines from the IRS regarding hydrogen incentives released with the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) last year, it is clear that supportive policy must be in place for green hydrogen to compete in existing hydrogen...

Enverus Press Release - Breaking down the CCUS basins
Energy Analytics Energy Transition

Panel discussion with CCUS experts from Enverus EVOLVE Conference Introduction CCUS offers a promising solution to curb greenhouse gas emissions by capturing CO2 from industrial sources and power plants and storing it underground. CCUS has gained significant attention in recent...

Analyst Takes
ByChris Griggs

As we usher in the month of August, it’s an ideal moment for retrospection on the past month’s shifts and trends in the energy sector. Our proficient Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) team has delved into critical trends and innovations,...

Energy Transition
ByCarson Kearl

The Vogtle Unit 3 nuclear reactor began its commercial operations at the end of July. Based in Georgia, the facility will provide clean electricity to the southeast U.S. for likely longer than the next half-century. This marks the first U.S....

Enverus News Release - Energy impacts of Gulf of Mexico hurricanes quantified
Trading and Risk

Navigating dynamic commodity markets and managing large volumes of data is no small task. That’s why we’ve built a powerful CTRM solution to help aggregate and leverage more than 500 data sources alongside your own proprietary data, providing an unsurpassed...

Energy Transition
ByScott Wilmot

Historical factors and trends are becoming less descriptive of future power demand. The growing pace of electrification and electric vehicle (EV) adoption are changing the power demand dynamics. At the same time, more customers are installing behind-the-meter (BTM) generation to...

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Register Today

Get Energy Transition Research updates straight to your inbox by filling out the form below.

Sign Up

Power Your Insights

Connect with an Expert

Access Product Tour

Speak to an Expert