Energy Analytics Geoscience Analytics

Deciphering Minerals Upside: An Analytics-Intensive Approach

byShawn Stuart

With West Texas Intermediate oil at $100+ per barrel and Henry Hub natural gas quadruple its 2022 open, non-operated interest investors have an unprecedented opportunity to cash in on commodity prices as each operator drills to drive their own capital return strategy. But absent a working interest, non-ops lack any decision-making power in an operator’s go forward development profile.  To buy minerals ahead of the drill bit and assess the changing value of an existing portfolio, non-operators need good leading indicators of producer next steps, starting with guidance and disclosures and graduating to a more nuanced analysis of operator behavior.

As investors, we can no longer rely solely on tried-and-true indicators of drilling, such as permits and rig activity (aka, “line of sight”). The industry is in flux and the playing field is repositioning as operator interest shifts to different U.S. basins, DUC inventory backlog continues to burn, M&A accelerates, and development responds more sluggishly to demand with operators seeking to return more value to shareholders instead of reinvesting all their profits. To estimate the timeframe over which their minerals will be developed, a non-operator needs to consider how acreage development will evolve for each operator active in their area given the range of options those operators have available and market pressure.  That requires analysis of proved developed producing (PDP) acreage on an operator-by-operator basis and untangling the complexities of proved undeveloped (PUD) reserves. It’s all about having the right data and workflow.

High grading operator PDP potential

The rising tide lifts all boats, but as mineral and royalty owners we certainly know that not all E&Ps are created equal or benefit uniformly from higher commodity prices. Low-cost operators and those with prime acreage positions and large drilling inventory are at an advantage. Even within a sub-basin, we shouldn’t think of E&Ps as uniform producers. Production can vary based on what formations are targeted (critical in the stacked pay of the Permian), an operator’s holdings across basins, production economics, and the range of hydrocarbons each operator produces (e.g., dry gas, grades of crude, NGL).

Using PRISM, we can begin assessing EUR based on type curves assigned to each well in an operator’s portfolio and see which locations E&Ps are most levered to. In just minutes, we can understand where an operator’s go forward production profile will move based on current production and inventory.

From a non-op investment point of view, it’s important for us to see who is most active in each basin (and not necessarily just our area of interest), how producers are shifting PDP focus, and what drilling activity is required to maintain decline profiles. For some operators, this profile might be maintained through continued development in the same areas based on inventory and rig activity. However, given ongoing repositioning, investors should never assume that operators will continue replacing production, even in areas where they have inventory.

Production by operator and allocation into each basin
Figure 1: Production by operator (left) and allocation into each basin (right).

Putting a value on undeveloped upside

Under the current state of the market, undeveloped drilling activity is the greatest source of uncertainty that requires a more complex analysis to assess PUD upside. We need to see ahead of the bit based on what is disclosed in filings and read between the lines to glean the value of undeveloped go forward production, land and drilling program economics. We also need to better assess the economics of each operator’s portfolio as they rearrange or refocus following M&A. At the end of the day, investors really want to know just how long they can continue to collect royalties from their portfolio.

Mining the Past for Insights

To understand how to move forward we need to understand historical activity to see how we arrived at today’s strong production output.

Using PRISM, we can look at well count over time across operator positions and see when and where production came online. From the historical well count chart, we can see well counts have returned to pre-pandemic levels. A shift in capital discipline and emphasis on free cash flow point toward sustained production and returns, which is great from a minerals and royalties perspective because it would indicate that new wells could be developed on our properties, adding to revenue streams. But we have noticed an interesting shift in production from the Delaware to the Midland Basin where a greater backlog of inventory (DUCs) exists.

Rig activity provides a better indicator of go forward PUD production. DUC draw down is impacting go forward development in the short term as drilling continues to lag pre-pandemic rig count (Figure 2), but it may not return to past levels and, from a non-op position, it’s important to dig deeper to determine whether this basin-level recovery trend will actually add any new production to our portfolio. Indeed, the following PRISM charts show that for one non-op interest owner in the Delaware the trend is flat compared to the steep uptick for the Permian.

Basin-level drililing vs. drilling actvity on a mineral company's position
Figure 2: Basin-level drilling vs. drilling activity on a mineral company’s position.

While Permian rig recovery has been steady, rig activity has been flat for some minerals-exposed companies in parts of the Delaware, as the above example illustrates. Continuing with this example in PRISM, we can dive into current rigs and allocation for the minerals exposure to identify the operators and regions at play. This is where line of sight can help reduce uncertainty of which wells will be put on production.

From PRISM we can easily see the operators who have line of sight wells in the minerals position and their status from permit to DUC and completion. We can then see which operators will contribute the most to the near-term production profile for our example minerals position. Using offset well analysis we can better forecast the go forward production profile and get accurate EURs for the formations DUCs are drilled in which will directly impact near term cashflow.

Operator benchmarking

Looking further ahead, it’s important for minerals and royalty investors to understand the economics of the land in their portfolio as well as the operators drilling the wells. From PRISM we can drill into operator benchmarking to assess the value of a mineral position’s economics and how operators compare on a peer-to-peer basis.

Breakeven for Delaware and Midland Basins based on associated LOE and productviity metrics
Figure 3: Breakeven for Delaware and Midland Basins based on associated LOE and productivity metrics.

The above scatterplot shows the relative strength of top operator wells (P10 – P90) and compares hydrocarbon recovery and costs to gauge the breakeven costs across the Permian. It’s clear that the Delaware Basin provides superior economics, but activity is shifting away to the Midland Basin. To untangle what is driving this trend, we’ll need to isolate operator activity for a clearer picture of go forward activity. From PRISM we can quickly identify Devon and EOG as the top producers in the Delaware.

Top operators in the Delaware Basin
Figure 4: Top operators in the Delaware Basin.

Even though overall production in the Delaware has leveled off, Devon’s rig count within the mineral position has dropped from 10 pre-pandemic rigs to two or three, which better informs our view of the go forward revenue stream. The operator has not pulled rigs completely out of the Delaware, but it has rearranged its rigs within Lee and Eddy Counties. With PRISM’s ability to overlay your own minerals and royalty position alongside operator acreage, inventory and activity, it’s easy to understand the upside.

Conclusion and key takeaways

Our industry has been rocked by market forces over the last two years, including a global pandemic, geopolitical events, Wall Street’s desire for disciplined growth and shareholder value, a hyperfocus on ESG, and the energy transition, all of which are shaping the go forward strategy for every energy company. The oil and gas industry of the past will not resemble the oil and gas industry of the future. As mineral and royalty investors, the evolving oil and gas landscape presents pitfalls and opportunities to realign. Now more than ever, analytics and contextualized data are what will make or break your portfolio going forward.

To get more details on how to better forecast production timing from line of sight well activity including Frac Crew tracking, and better understand how operator development strategies will affect development of your minerals, email [email protected] or call 1-800-282-4245.

Enverus’ forecasting tools provide pre-generated and customizable production forecasts and economics in one platform to gain visibility into operator behavior, near-term cashflow, and asset value to help non-operators confidently make business decisions.

Shawn Stuart

Shawn Stuart

Shawn joined in Enverus in January 2018 and is a vice president with the Commercial Intelligence team. He graduated from Union College in Schenectady, New York, in 2013 with a degree in managerial economics and earned his CFA designation in 2019. With a focus on SMID-cap operators, Shawn contributes to company valuations, comparative analysis and financial modeling across the E&P sector. His areas of expertise include financial modeling and analysis, SMID-cap valuations and market sentiment. He is based in Calgary, Alberta.

Subscribe to the Enverus Blog

A weekly update on the latest “no-fluff” insight and analysis of the energy industry.

Related Content

Energy Analytics Energy Transition
ByAndrew Gillick

In case you missed it, Enverus virtually hosted EVOLVE, our flagship conference, May 16-17. The event included two full days of presentations, panels and keynotes, distilling the most relevant data and thoughts on the industry today.  Below Andrew Gillick, managing director...

Energy Analytics Other
ByShane Reddell

In the current landscape of heightened environmental and social consciousness, upstream oil and gas companies face significant challenges in achieving favorable refinancing for their existing credit facilities. These challenges are compounded by the recent volatility in the debt markets and...

Energy Analytics Intelligence Publications
ByMaurice Smith

Wildfires that have already scorched more than double the average annual fire destruction across Alberta forced the shut-in of more than 300,000 boe/d while threatening future shuttering of output from the so-far largely unaffected oil sands region. Record temperatures saw...

Energy Analytics Energy Transition
ByHeather Leahey

CO2 containment risk has become one of the most popular topics among our clients evaluating CCUS projects. Operators need to understand and evaluate subsurface features that could trigger CO2 migration and containment losses as well as introduce additional safety, reputational...

Energy Analytics Energy Transition
ByRyan Luther

Anyone who thinks spending time at a public charging station is a blocker to buying an electric vehicle (EV) might want to consider the numbers behind EV and internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle refueling times. The answer is that it...

Enverus Blog - 6 tax preparation tips for mineral and royalty managers
Energy Analytics
BySilas Martin

Recent years have been a roller coaster for mineral buyers, from record low commodity prices to highs for oil and natural gas in the last year. Going forward, challenges and opportunities will be plentiful. We expect oil prices between $80...

Power and Renewables
ByKenneth Curtis

It’s that time of year when generator and transmission outages are at their peak in PJM. The first half of April has not disappointed volatility-wise as the WHUB/NIHUB spread has set new 30-day highs largely driven by congestion. Figure 1:...

Enverus Blog - April's energy outlook: Analyst insights you can't miss
Analyst Takes Energy Analytics
ByChris Griggs

May marks a new month, and it’s essential to assess the energy landscape of April. Our Enverus Intelligence® | Research (EIR) team has scrutinized critical trends and advancements, delivering to you insightful analyst takes that can shape your business decisions....

Energy Analytics
ByCayley Krynowsky

Inventory is king in 2023. Operators and investors alike are more concerned than ever about remaining inventory – who has it, where is it, and will it be economic? To answer these questions, most turn to the tried-and-true, but also...

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Let’s get started!

We’ll follow up right away to show you a quick product tour.

Sign up for our Blog

Access Product Tour

Speak to an Expert

Book a Demo