Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform

Share

DI Transform is best known for its multivariate analytics package, which is like saying Texas is best known for its horses. That is to say, there’s a lot more to it. DI Transform is designed to be an all-encompassing geoscience application. DI Transform can handle everything from planning the first test well to extracting powerful visuals for investor meetings. As a solution architect for DI Transform, I’m often asked “Can DI Transform do x?” The answer is almost always yes.

One thing I’ve never been asked is “Can DI Transform incorporate geothermal data?” And the answer would be yes. Geothermal data has applications beyond just commercial geothermal energy and academic research. Geothermal affects engineering considerations while drilling a well, and it offers clues as to the whereabouts of ore minerals and oil and gas reservoirs. Organic matter must undergo heating to generate petroleum. The heat in the subsurface comes from heat flow from the mantle and radiogenic heating in the earth’s crust.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
A map of temperatures at 3.5 km (~11,482 ft) across the US (SMU Geothermal Laboratory). The red spot in the northwest corner of Wyoming is the Yellowstone volcanic hotspot.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
The table depicts temperatures at which reservoirs reach various levels of thermal maturity. The oil window occurs when the temperature is between approximately 140°F and 320 °F. Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources

Temperature logs (of mnemonic DTL) are commonly recorded while drilling. These logs help delineate different formations based on changes in temperature gradient that are caused by their unique thermal conductivity. Once a typical geothermal gradient has been established for an area, anomalies can be explored. Downhole temperatures also play a part in identifying safe operating parameters for injection wells. According to the logging company Analog, “Losses behind pipe from the injection zone, as well as casing and tubing leaks, can be detected on both flowing and shut in temperature surveys and exhibit a ‘loss’ signature”.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
A temperature log is typically a smooth line reflecting the thermal gradient. Changes in the gradient are caused by rocks having different thermal conductivities. (Division for Hydrogeology and Engineering Geology of South Vietnam)

Since universities are the leading producer of borehole temperature data, it is widely available and free to the public. A few sources are listed below.

  • National Geothermal Data System: Data is contributed by universities, government, and private companies. All 50 State Geological Surveys contribute. In addition to a wide range of data types available for independent download, data streams are available as OGC, Web Map Service, and Web Feature Service, all of which DI Transform support. Data on this site is focused on the United States, but also includes some other areas. https://geothermaldata.org/
  • SMU Geothermal Lab: Established in 1970, the research group is a leader in geothermal data collection and mapping. The official Geothermal Map of North America relies heavily on data gathered by the group. https://geothermal.smu.edu

USING GEOTHERMAL DATA WITH YOUR DI TRANSFORM PROJECT

Some subsurface temperature data comes with only latitude-longitude, but most of it comes with an associated API number since the temperature is usually measured in a borehole. The best way to import the data is to have a project already populated with wells and tie the temperature data to individual wellbores by API. I usually throw out any well header data from the geothermal data and rely solely on the header data from Drillinginfo since it is updated and quality controlled.

We will first look at building a temperature-depth curve, and then explore how to create a temperature surface.

BUILD A REGIONAL TEMPERATURE-DEPTH CURVE

For building a local temperature depth curve, a simple data set with just bottomhole temperatures will suffice. I used the Aggregated Well Data because it contains data points all over the country and I can use a copy of this single file and parse it down to what I’m interested in. This data set has one temperature data point per well, so it can be imported into DI Transform as a scalar value. Simply define a custom attribute and choose temperature as the property type. DI Transform accepts temperature as Celsius, Kelvin, Fahrenheit, and Rankine, as well as delta values for temperature. You’ll also need to import the measurement depth column as a scalar attribute. Be careful- with this type of data, temperature is usually reported in Celsius and depth is in meters. You can import the data this way and then choose other units for display later.
Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
A view of temperature over depth in Andrews County. Display units are configurable. Depth is shown here in feet and temperature in Fahrenheit.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
Place temperature on the Y axis to calculate the geothermal gradient. For this data set, the geothermal gradient would be T(°F)=0.01173(ft)+ 55.67.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
Build a depth profile to look at temperature. Use the polygon tool to select an individual data point and view information for that well.

BUILD A TEMPERATURE HORIZON IN DEPTH

To do this, you will want to retain latitude, longitude, depth, and temperature. The horizon is created by first gridding temperature on X-Y and then projecting that onto a 3-D surface defined by the point set.
1) Import latitude, longitude, and depth (m) as a point set. Be sure to choose the correct reference coordinate system (NAD 27 for this project) or latitude/longitude will not be an option.
2) Like in the previous example, import depth and temperature (corrected) as well scalars using API number
3) Use the 2D Mapping Utility (basemap view) to create a horizon version based on our point set. This is just a surface conforming to the where the temperatures were measured.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
A depth horizon was created from our point set using the 2D Mapping Utility

4) Repeat the process using temperature as the input data and assign this as a property of the newly created depth horizon version.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
Designate the temperature as a property of the depth horizon in order to view temperatures along a surface.

Heating Up: How to Visualize Geothermal Data in DI Transform
A 3-D surface representing the temperature data. Well sticks are shown where there was associated temperature data. Hovering over any spot on the horizon will give you the interpolated temperature at that point (depth being fixed to the horizon).

DI Transform is a powerful tool with far-reaching applications. By combining a wide array of available import options with a robust statistical and processing package, Transform is slowly proving itself as a valuable tool for universities and researchers of all kinds.

Your Turn

What do you think? Leave a comment below.

The following two tabs change content below.

Ashley Justinic

Ashley Justinic is a Solution Architect for Drillinginfo. She is part of the Transform team, responsible for facilitating the success of client geoscience projects using Transform software. Ashley earned a Bachelor's Degree in Geology at SMU in 2010, and a Master's Degree in Geophysics at SMU in 2012.